PDF24Comparisons

PDF24 alternative for automatic redaction

Looking for a PDF24 alternative? PDF24 redacts PDFs for free in the browser, but only the terms you search for. This comparison shows how PDF24 redaction works, where it falls short, which alternatives exist – and when Diskretio is the better fit because it detects names, addresses and ID numbers automatically, in PDF and Office files.

HOFFMANN & PARTNERS LLP

Solicitors · Barristers · Notaries

H&P

14 Fleet Street · London EC4Y 1AA · +44 20 7946 0123

Acme Construction Ltd

Attn: Mr. Richard Hale

8 Industrial Way

Manchester M1 2AB

London, 14 October 2026

Our ref: HP-2026/0412 · Your ref: AC/rh-77

Smith v Acme Construction Ltd – defects at 3 Linden Road, Manchester

Dear Mr. Hale,

We act for Mr. John Smith, date of birth: March 4, 1970. A signed letter of authority is enclosed.

Our client notified you of the waterproofing defects on 2 September 2026 and set a deadline which has passed without response. We hereby demand payment of £18,450.00 by 28 October 2026 to account GB82 WEST 1234 5698 7654 32.

Should you have any questions, please contact Ms. Anna Webb at a.webb@hoffmann-partners.co.uk.

Yours sincerely,

Julia Hoffmann

Partner

Page 1 of 3

Your formats and the AI tools you work with afterwards

  • Word
  • Excel
  • PowerPoint
  • Outlook (emails)
  • PDF
  • Scans & photos
  • TXT Text & CSV
  • ChatGPT
  • Claude
  • Microsoft Copilot
  • Gemini
  • Mistral
  • DeepL
  • Perplexity

Key takeaways

  • PDF24 is free, ad-funded and needs no account: you draw boxes or search a term and click Redact all matches.
  • On save, PDF24 converts affected pages to images – the hidden text is gone for good, but those pages are no longer searchable.
  • PDF24 does not detect personal data: every name, account number and spelling variant is your job.
  • The PDF24 Creator works offline but is Windows-only; Mac and Linux users rely on the online tool.
  • Pick an alternative when you need automatic detection, Word/Excel support, scans in one step or batch processing.

What to check when redacting with PDF24

  • Search each name and number yourself – PDF24 does not detect personal data automatically
  • Use Redact all matches, but check spelling variants, initials and email addresses separately
  • Make scanned PDFs searchable first with the separate OCR tool
  • Check headers, footers, tables and signature blocks on every page
  • Expect redacted pages to be saved as images – their text is no longer selectable
  • Review document metadata such as author and title separately
  • Run the copy test on the downloaded file: select a redacted area and paste – nothing should appear

How it works

  1. 1

    Upload file

    Upload the PDF, scan, Word or Excel file to Diskretio – one at a time or as a batch.

  2. 2

    Review matches

    Names, addresses, bank details, dates of birth and more are detected automatically, without typing search terms. Add your own terms with word lists from the Pro plan.

  3. 3

    Download redacted

    Get the file without metadata plus a report of what was replaced – Office files in their original format, PDFs with a clean, searchable text layer.

Side-by-side comparison. Diskretio vs. PDF24 Tools

Criterion DiskretioPDF24 PDF24 Tools
Price10 pages/month free, plans from €24/monthFree, ad-funded, no sign-up
Automatic detection17 categories, e.g. names, addresses, IBAN, tax IDsNo, searches the terms you enter
FormatsPDF, Word, Excel, PowerPoint, images, textPDF
Text after redactionSearchable: new PDF with a clean text layer; Office files stay textAffected pages become images without text
ScansOCR in the same stepOCR as a separate tool
Offline useNo, web app and REST APIYes, PDF24 Creator for Windows
StorageOriginals not stored, EU servers, DPA includedDeleted within 1 hour, EU servers

Our verdict

For a single PDF where you know exactly what to remove, PDF24 is free and quick – the better choice if you want to pay nothing, skip sign-up or work fully offline on Windows. Diskretio pays off when names and IDs should be detected automatically, across several documents or scans, or in Word and Excel files that must stay in their format.

How does PDF24 redaction work?

PDF24's Redact PDF tool runs in any browser at tools.pdf24.org, with no installation or account. The workflow is simple:

  • Open Redact PDF and choose your file or drag it into the drop area – it opens in the PDF24 editor
  • Draw black boxes over text, images or areas you want to remove
  • To catch repeated terms, use the search in the sidebar, enter a word or phrase and click Redact all matches
  • Review the list of redactions in the sidebar and remove any you don't need
  • Save with the disk icon and download the result

Search finds only exactly what you type. Run separate searches for surnames, initials, email addresses and nicknames, or you will miss occurrences.

Is PDF24 safe for redacting sensitive documents?

The method itself is sound. According to PDF24, all affected pages are converted to raster images on save, replacing the original page content, so the text under the boxes cannot be recovered. That is far safer than drawing a black rectangle in an ordinary PDF viewer, which only covers the text.

On privacy, PDF24's FAQ says processing servers are located in data centers within the EU, transfers are encrypted and files are deleted automatically within one hour of processing. The service is run by geek software GmbH, a German company, and funded by advertising.

The real risk is human: whatever you don't search for or mark stays in the document. That is manageable for a two-page invoice, much less so for an 80-page case file with twenty people in it.

Whether you may upload client, patient or employee data to a free online service depends on your obligations, such as needing a data processing agreement under GDPR. Check with your data protection officer – this is not legal advice.

Where PDF24 falls short

PDF24 is great when you know exactly what to remove from a single PDF. It gets harder in these cases:

  • No automatic detection: the tool description mentions no pattern search or detection of names, addresses or bank details
  • Spelling variants: “Dr. Anna Smith”, “A. Smith” and “Ms Smith” are three separate searches
  • Scans: without OCR first, search finds nothing and every box is drawn by hand
  • Searchability: redacted pages become images, so their remaining text can't be searched or copied
  • Formats: the tool works on PDFs; Word, Excel and PowerPoint files have to be converted first
  • Volume: every document is handled individually in the editor, with no batch redaction using the same rules
  • Platforms: the offline PDF24 Creator is Windows-only

Best PDF24 alternatives for redaction

Which alternative fits depends on whether you want a free manual tool, desktop software or automatic detection. The details below come from each vendor's own pages as of November 2026; prices and features change, so check before you decide.

ToolHow it finds contentFormatsCostPlatform
PDF24 ToolsTerms you typePDFFree, ad-fundedBrowser; Creator for Windows
Adobe Acrobat ProSearch terms, word lists and patterns (phone, email, credit card, SSN, dates)PDFSubscriptionWindows, Mac
PDF-XChange EditorSearch terms, patterns and regular expressionsPDFOne-time licenceWindows
SmallpdfManual markingPDF, Word, Excel, PowerPoint, imagesFree with daily limit, Pro planBrowser
DiskretioAutomatic detection, 17 categories in English and GermanPDF, Word, Excel, PowerPoint, images, text10 pages/month free, plans from €24/monthBrowser and REST API

PDF24 vs. Diskretio: which one should you use?

Both remove content permanently, but they solve different problems. PDF24 is a manual editor: you decide box by box. Diskretio is automatic detection: it finds personal data in 17 categories and you review the result using the report.

Your situationBetter fitWhy
One PDF, a few known passagesPDF24Free, no account, done in minutes
Files must never leave your PCPDF24 Creator (Windows)Works offline
Long file with many peopleDiskretioFinds names, addresses and IDs without search terms
Word, Excel or PowerPointDiskretioEdited in the original format, layout kept
Scans and photosDiskretioOCR and redaction in one step
Preparing text for ChatGPT or ClaudeDiskretioPlaceholders like [PERSON_1] keep the text understandable
Recurring team workflowsDiskretioBatch upload, shared word lists and REST API from Pro

How automatic redaction with Diskretio works

Upload a PDF, scan, Word, Excel or PowerPoint file and choose a strategy: classic black redaction (█████), placeholders such as [PERSON_1], or realistic fake data from the Pro plan. Detection works in English and German and covers names, companies, addresses, email, phone numbers, IBANs, card numbers, tax and social security numbers, ID and passport numbers, case numbers and dates of birth, plus your own custom terms.

PDFs and images are rebuilt from page images: redactions are burned in, and an invisible text layer holds only the cleaned text. The result stays searchable while nothing from the original file is carried over – no metadata, comments, form fields or attachments. Word, Excel and PowerPoint are edited in place, with comments, tracked changes and document properties cleaned.

Originals are not stored, processing happens in the EU, and a data processing agreement is included in every plan. As with any tool, review important documents against the report before sharing them.

What Diskretio does not do: it doesn't detect objects such as buildings or vehicles in photos (faces are painted over), and it doesn't process video, audio or email files. For those, a manual tool is still needed.

FAQ

Questions. Answered briefly.

Try it with your own document

10 pages per month are free. No subscription, no credit card.